PDA

View Full Version : Manhattan Valley Historic District


Fahzee
January 25th, 2007, 02:28 PM
My apologies if there's already a thread about this - I couldn't find it


BY GARY SHAPIRO - Staff Reporter of the Sun
January 25, 2007
URL: http://www.nysun.com/article/47372

An enclave of Rennaisance Revival and Queen Anne-style row houses along Manhattan Avenue between 104th and 106th streets in Manhattan may be designated a historic district. The area took its first steps toward designation last night at a community meeting where building owners and neighbors discussed the landmarks process.
"The area has that special sense of place that you look for in a historic district," the director of Landmark West!, Kate Wood, an advocate for designating the area the Manhattan Valley Historic District, said. She said the area above 96th Street has not received the same amount of landmark designation attention as the area below.
Gone is the time when drug deals, empty tree wells, and neglected buildings with squatters dotted the sloping area. These days, strollers may see Caribbean food, Southern cooking, a crepe place, and Argentinean steak joint alongside chain stores.
A historic district gives residents assurance that the area where they are living is not going to be altered inconceivably, the executive director of the Historic Districts Council, Simeon Bankoff, said. Owners who want to make building changes have to get approval from the Landmarks Preservation Commission.
The executive director of Manhattan Value Development Corp., Donna Gibbons, said there are burdens as well as benefits from the designation. Ms. Gibbons, whose organization develops low- and moderate-income housing in the area, said a historic designation would make it more costly to do renovations.
A professor at Columbia University, Andrew Dolkart, said the row houses in Manhattan Valley designed for middle-class families were among the most interesting on the Upper West Side because of their modest scale and fine detail.
He cited the "dynamic rooftop silhouettes, a rich sense of texture, and an interesting use of materials, all combining to create an exciting ensemble of houses."
The cancer hospital on the corner of 106th Street and Central Park West, which is now pricey apartments, is a distinctive building in the neighborhood.
The treasurer of the Duke Ellington Boulevard Neighborhood Association, Jean Jaworek, who moved to the area around 1981, said property values had risen significantly and that she feared for the neighborhood's diversity. Through the decades, German, Irish, Puerto Rican, Dominican, and Mexican immigrants have lived in the area, which has seen an influx of young urban professionals and Columbia University students. The district manager for the Columbus Amsterdam Business Improvement District, Peter Arndtsen, said the prices of townhouses have doubled or tripled in the past decade. Crime has been relatively low.
The meeting last night was part of the public information process. If the LPC eventually votes to calendar the issue, a public hearing will take place at which the public will give testimony.

lofter1
January 25th, 2007, 03:30 PM
Manhattan Valley Historic District

Designation 'Wish List'

http://www.landmarkwest.org/advocacy/wishlist.html

http://www.landmarkwest.org/advocacy/ad_06/large/08.jpg

LANDMARK WEST! has long advocated the designation of a small district on the blocks adjacent to the New York Cancer Hospital (Towers Nursing Home).

This district would incorporate the modest Queen Anne rowhouses erected on Manhattan Avenue and 105th and 106th Streets shortly after the Ninth Avenue elevated opened with a station stop at 104 th Street. The proposed district includes 39 rowhouses designed by C.P.H. Gilbert, Edward Angell, and J.M. Dunn between 1885 and 1889.

lofter1
January 25th, 2007, 03:34 PM
Info from Hearing at CB7, with MAP of proposed Historic District [pdf] ...


Manhattan Valley Historic District Hearing (http://www.cb7.org/announce_mvflyer.pdf)

Fahzee
February 13th, 2007, 11:01 PM
the Landmarks Preservation Council voted today to Calendar the Manhattan Valley Historic District. No word (yet) on when the District will come up for a full vote, but these row houses are nominally safe for the immediate future

ablarc
February 13th, 2007, 11:25 PM
http://66.230.220.70/images/post/newyorkcity/0014.JPG

Fahzee
March 9th, 2007, 02:25 PM
The full vote on landmarking this district will happen March 13th

ablarc
April 1st, 2007, 11:59 AM
The full vote on landmarking this district will happen March 13th
Outcome?

Fahzee
April 4th, 2007, 12:19 PM
I'm actually not positive - After March 13th I searched around to see if there was any info, but the Landmarks Webpage, as well as the webpages for "Landmarks West! (the organization that put together the bid for landmarking) and the Historic District Council blog had no mention of the actual vote

My guess is that the vote was held off for whatever reason, and they have yet to schedule a new vote.

pianoman11686
May 17th, 2007, 12:59 AM
From http://cityrealty.com/new_developments:

Manhattan Avenue Historic District created 16-MAY-07

http://www.cityrealty.com/graphics/uploads/1179349779_manhattan_ave.jpg

The Landmarks Preservation Commission voted unanimously yesterday to designate a portion of Manhattan Avenue on the Upper West Side as the city's 87th historic district.

Located between Central Park West and Columbus Avenue, the Manhattan Avenue Historic District comprises 40 buildings that were mostly constructed between 1886 and 1889 between 104th and 106th Streets.

Unlike many of Manhattan's earlier row houses, which were primarily built with brownstone facades in the classical style, the commission noted that the structures in the new district combine Gothic, Queen Anne and Romanesque features.

Manhattan Avenue was originally called "New" Avenue when it was created in 1868 and it starts at 100th Street and continues to 125th Street, where it merges with St. Nicholas Avenue.

"The picturesque buildings in this enclave will continue to maintain their scale and cohesive character with this designation," said Commission Chairman Robert B. Tierney. "They are vivid reminders of the early development of the West Side of Manhattan in the 19th century," he said, "and even with the neighborhood's ongoing development in this century, these historic treasures will live on for future generations as part of New York's newest historic district."

The historic district features three groups of row houses that were constructed and designed by different architects and developers.

The earliest row, located on the west side of Manhattan Avenue, between 105th and 106th streets, was designed by the architect Joseph M. Dunn, who is responsible for a number of warehouses and buildings on Ward's, Blackwell's, Hart's, and Randall's islands in the 1880s.

C. P. (Charles Pierrepont) H. Gilbert, a successful residential architect who built 20 houses on Montgomery Place in the Park Slope Historic District in Brooklyn, and mansions for Felix Warburg and F.W. Woolworth, designed the second row that stands directly east. This block, the commission observed, has "a lively and jagged profile and incorporates features associated with the Queen Anne and Romanesque Revival styles."

The third group, located to south, on the west side of Manhattan Avenue, was designed by Edward L. Angell. These brick and stone-faced houses also combined Queen Anne and Romanesque Revival elements, including stoops with iron railings, terracotta reliefs, projecting metal bay windows, and unusual cornices crowned by sunburst pediments.

The district also includes a dormitory and an X-ray laboratory that were part of the former New York Cancer Hospital complex, a designated New York City Landmark. Completed in 1926 and located at 34-36 West 106th Street, the dormitory housed hospital staff, and was built in the French Renaissance style and now houses a youth hostel. The neo-Gothic-style X-ray building, at 19-37 West 105th Street, was built in 1917.

The Landmarks Preservation Commission has now granted landmark status to more than 23,000 buildings, including 1,159 individual landmarks, 108 interior landmarks, nine scenic landmarks and 87 historic districts in all five boroughs.

Fabrizio
May 17th, 2007, 03:41 AM
Viva community activism:

http://www.landmarkwest.org/about/index.html

http://www.landmarkwest.org/