Page 31 of 39 FirstFirst ... 21272829303132333435 ... LastLast
Results 451 to 465 of 573

Thread: InterActiveCorp HQ - 555 West 18th Street @ West Street - by Frank Gehry

  1. #451

    Default

    I think the contrast with the brick and grit of the neighborhood works better than it would with the polish of a beaux-arts building. A nice surprise moving along 11th Ave.

    I hope 100 11th Ave doesn't ruin the effect.

  2. #452

    Default

    Ablarc writes: "Vacation seems to have honed your observations".

    Nah. I'm just repeating myself. Over a year ago I said (dec 5th 2005 ):

    "The building looks delicate...subtle... not the usual Ghery train wreck."

    Ghery next to the classical? In this case Cass Gilbert. from April 3rd, 2006:

    "BTW: take another look at the Reade street rendering.... ok, no great fan of Ghery, but wouldn´t that be an interesting place for him to squeeze in a building... imagine him doing a building that would be one big beaux-arts flourish..."

    (btw: I was surprised and disappointed you were relatively easy on the architecture of 17 State Street. C'mon Ablarc, I know you know better...)

  3. #453

    Default

    I drove by this building at night last week, and I must say, the difference IS night and day. During the day, it is a kind of cool building, but also a little off. At night, however, with the lights on, it is a dreamlike.

  4. #454

    Default very cool, one of Gehry's best

    its so much better at night

  5. #455
    Build the Tower Verre antinimby's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    in Limbo
    Posts
    8,976

    Default That NY Times article in full...

    Gehry’s New York Debut: Subdued Tower of Light



    Frank Gehry designed this Manhattan building, the home to Barry Diller’s
    media and Internet business.


    By NICOLAI OUROUSSOFF
    Published: March 22, 2007

    In the year since the concrete frame of Frank Gehry’s first New York building began to rise along the West Side Highway in Chelsea, architecture fans have been quarrelling over its design. Are the curvaceous glass forms of the IAC headquarters building, evoking the crisp pleats of a skirt, a bold departure from Manhattan’s hard-edged corporate towers? Or are they proof that Mr. Gehry’s radical days are behind him?

    Well, both. Mr. Gehry is adding a much-needed touch of lightness to the Manhattan skyline just as the city finally emerges from a period of mourning. The IAC building, serving as world headquarters for Barry Diller’s media and Internet empire, joins a growing list of new projects that reflect how mainstream developers in the city are significantly raising the creative stakes after decades of settling for bland, soul-sapping office buildings.

    Yet the building, which is not quite complete, also feels oddly tame. For those who have followed Mr. Gehry’s creative career, these easy, fluid forms are a marked departure from the complex, fragmented structures of his youth. Rather than mining rich new creative territory, Mr. Gehry, now 78, seems to be holding back.

    The results — almost pristine by Mr. Gehry’s standards — suggest the casual confidence of an aging virtuoso rather than the brash innovation of a rowdy outsider.

    New York has long been a frustrating place for Mr. Gehry. It has taken him decades to land a major commission here, and now the IAC building joins a string of high-profile towers, all part of an effort to transform a noisy strip of the West Side Highway into a glamorous waterfront promenade for the kind of wealthy socialites who once scorned him. Three luxury high-rise apartment buildings by Richard Meier, with tenants like Martha Stewart and Calvin Klein, are a 10-minute walk to the south. A much-anticipated residential tower by the French architect Jean Nouvel is beginning to rise just across West 19th Street.

    Mr. Gehry’s structure, the most fanciful of these, looks best when approached from a distance. Glimpsed between Chelsea’s weathered brick buildings, its strangely chiseled forms reflect the surrounding sky, so that its surfaces can seem to be dissolving. As you circle to the north, however, its forms become more symmetrical and sharp-edged, evoking rows of overlapping sails or knifelike pleats. Viewed from the south, the forms appear more blocky. This constantly changing character imbues the building’s exterior with an enigmatic beauty. And it reflects Mr. Gehry’s subtle understanding of context. Rather than parodying the architectural style of the surrounding buildings, he plays against them, drawing them into a bigger urban composition. The sail-like curves of the west facade seem to be braced against the roar of the passing cars. The blockier forms in back lock the composition into the lower brick buildings that extend to the east.

    But far too many of the rough edges have been smoothed over. As a young architect Mr. Gehry often said that he tried to capture the raw energy of a construction site in his finished buildings; he was actually taking aim at a complacent status quo. Forms collide, materials clash, buildings tear open to reveal the crude steel structures beneath. Later in his career, as the work became more surreal, sexual imagery performed the same function: forms pull apart to suggest a hiked dress or gently parting legs.

    The lobby entries of the IAC headquarters are discreetly located on the two side streets, giving the building’s main facade a smooth, uniform appearance. Horizontal, fritted white bands line the windows, an oddly decorative element meant to control the flow of light inside. The windows’ prefabricated panels meet the ground abruptly, their aluminum frames lining up end to end in a neat grid. They have neither the compulsive precision of a Meier building nor the raw, exposed quality of Mr. Gehry’s early work. Instead they look, well, tasteful.

    This toned-down, more accessible approach continues into the lobby, conceived as a public living room for the neighborhood. Its back wall is dominated by an 118-foot-long video wall, which will project video art or abstract color compositions. A sinuous maple bench snakes its way around one end of the room. A staggered row of titled columns runs along the zigzagging glass facade overlooking the highway, giving the room a slight air of instability. The effect conjures up a luxurious fish tank, a nice metaphor for our narcissistic era.

    As you travel deeper into the building, what first seems tame becomes more rigid. The floors that house the main corporate offices are dominated by a two-story atrium that overlooks the roof of the Chelsea Piers and the Hudson River, the kind of tough waterfront view from which Mr. Gehry once drew his inspiration. But the room is bloodless. The translucent glass partitions that surround the atrium are stiff and flat. A curved staircase, clad in pretentious tigerwood with brushed stainless steel handrails, looks imported from a Park Avenue office building. It may qualify as the most blandly corporate space Mr. Gehry has created.


    An unfinished atrium staircase.

    Compare this with the service stairwell at the back of the building. Made of rough exposed concrete, the 10-story staircase is pulled back from the glass facade, creating a narrow, vertigo-inducing slot that allows you to peer down into an outdoor courtyard. The staircase overlooks a romantic, perfectly framed view of the Empire State Building, but the clash of raw concrete, glass and aluminum has more in sympathy with the surrounding rooftops: a clear indication of where Mr. Gehry’s heart lies. It may be the most gorgeous service staircase anywhere in New York. (It has now been painted various shades of yellow, however, dulling the effect.)

    But it is when you step onto the sixth-floor corporate terrace that you glean what’s missing from the design. Leaning back against the rail, you get your first close look at the glass cladding on the upper floors, at a point where the building narrows. The faceted geometry here is more extreme, the connections between the glass panels more awkward.

    Joints don’t line up perfectly; corners look hurriedly patched together. At certain points the unusual curvature of a window, created by the building’s odd geometry, makes it impossible to span the opening with a single piece of glass, and the additional mullion creates an odd, patchwork pattern.

    The effect bristles with energy, as if the building were beginning to crack at the seams. It brings to mind early Gehry projects like the 1972 Ron Davis Studio in Malibu or the 1989 Vitra Design Museum in Weil am Reim, Germany.
    Neither work is perfect, but their imperfections are important. What you feel is someone struggling to make sense of something he has yet to fully grasp — the incompleteness of the creative struggle.

    It is a reminder that Mr. Gehry’s courage as an architect has stemmed in part from his distaste for perfection, for architectural purity — which in his mind comes perilously close to oppression. His aim has been to redeem the corners of the world that we often dismiss as crude, cheap and ugly. He intuitively understood that what seems ugly now may be only unfamiliar. If the ideas underlying a design are strong enough, its beauty would eventually reveal itself.

    The IAC building is elegant architecture. But it doesn’t make us rethink who we are.

    Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company

  6. #456

    Default

    The fritted windows ruin this building for me during the daytime. They impose a completely artificial geometry: dark horizontal bands that compete with the vertical expression of those sinuous "folds." The effect is very similar in a way to the NYTimes building, where the openings in the exterior rods create a horizontal banding effect, particularly on the east and west facades, that strains against the verticality of the tower. Ouroussoff's IAC appraisal, like most critical assessments of this building I've read, touches on the window openings only in passing, referring to them as "an oddly decorative element." I find it surprising that more critics don't deal with the windows at greater length; they are a defining characteristic of its daytime appearance, in my opinion. I agree the Gehry looks gorgeous at night, or at twilight, with the interior lights blazing. I think with a different window treatment it could look almost just as great during the day: my recommendation would be to decrease the contrast between the transparent and the translucent portions, or make all the glass the same transparency. I guess most people aren't bothered by this as much as I am.

  7. #457

    Default

    Antinimby, I posted all that texy on the previous page.

  8. #458
    Build the Tower Verre antinimby's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    in Limbo
    Posts
    8,976

    Default



    Oops but hey, at least I threw in a couple of nice new pics with mine, right?

  9. #459

    Talking

    Yes you did. And for that you deserve a cookie!

  10. #460

    Default

    I say: Buy that man a beer!

    The article is so-so.

  11. #461
    Forum Veteran MidtownGuy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    East Midtown
    Posts
    6,832

    Default

    the light was good today:











    I can't stop taking pictures of this thing. Everytime I skate by, out comes the camera. Gotta get over there at night though...

  12. #462

  13. #463
    The Dude Abides
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    NYC - Financial District
    Posts
    4,418

    Default

    If you allow me, I'll add to it: arrestingly beautiful.

  14. #464

    Default



    forgot i had this

  15. #465

    Wink

    Nice looking Building

Similar Threads

  1. Queensboro (59th Street) Bridge
    By Edward in forum New York City Guide For Visitors
    Replies: 27
    Last Post: March 10th, 2015, 05:10 AM
  2. Tweed Courthouse - 52 Chambers Street - by John Kellum / Leopold Eidlitz
    By Edward in forum New York City Guide For Visitors
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: December 30th, 2010, 09:17 PM
  3. 69th street Ferry - Old pictures
    By BILL in forum New York City Guide For Visitors
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: November 23rd, 2008, 09:33 AM
  4. West Midtown Ferry Terminal on Pier 79
    By Edward in forum New York City Guide For Visitors
    Replies: 27
    Last Post: November 12th, 2005, 01:23 AM
  5. Neon for the 59th Street Marine Transfer Station
    By Edward in forum New York City Guide For Visitors
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: August 24th, 2005, 11:04 PM

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  


Google+ - Facebook - Twitter - Meetup

Edward's photos on Flickr - Wired New York on Flickr - In Queens - In Red Hook - Bryant Park - SQL Backup Software